Unless you’ve lived under a rock for the last 2 weeks you’re probably aware of some drama happening in the Southern Baptist Convention. In what is often called the #MeToo movement coming to the SBC, past actions and comments by Dr. Paige Patterson, the president of Southwestern Baptist Theological Seminary, have come to light that seem to indicate a belittling stance towards women. These include the firing of a professor, pastoral counsel given to an abused wife, and sexually charged comments about a teenage girl. (There’s also the firing of a PHD student, but that’s actually another issue.)
As I have watched this story unfold I have wrestled with whether or not to jump into the fray, and frankly whether or not the fray should even exist. I’ve seen many comments on Twitter/etc. stating that Christians should not be discussing these types of issues on Twitter and in the blogosphere, and that the public statements against Dr. Patterson’s actions are slander and unbiblical actions against a Christian brother. Is this public conversation inappropriate or sinful?
I want to be clear up front: some of it is. Some of the things I have read are clearly personal attacks against my brother that I can only assume come from a past injury or long-seated dislike. Some of the things I have read are blind, idolatrous defenses of a man that compare Dr. Patterson to the Kingdom of God and Jesus Himself. There is shame on both of our houses.
However, put the crazies aside and there is an appropriate and necessary conversation happening that I believe has a biblical foundation. I have always been taught that leaders who fail in public are to be admonished in public. At my church we have established this as the precedent for the pastor (myself) and deacon leadership, based on Paul’s words in 1 Timothy 5:19-20.
Do not entertain an accusation against an elder unless it is brought by two or three witnesses. But those elders who are sinning you are to reprove before everyone, so that the others may take warning.
It was under this biblical heading that I stepped into the fray. Dr. Patterson fits the term elder in SBC life. The accusations I have heard against him come from multiple sources. Therefore the Church is correct to publicly call for repentance and a change of action. I participated in this action by sharing a blog by Wade Burleson that I thought not only correctly called for repentance by Dr. Patterson but addressed some underlying doctrinal stances that I believe have fed into and for too long have justified this type of sinful behavior. I realize I’m a nobody and that my tweet has affected almost no one, but I felt compelled to say something because of the 1 Timothy teaching.
But if you’ll look back to 1 Timothy 5:17 there is another teaching:
The elders who direct the affairs of the church well are worthy of double honor, especially those whose work is preaching and teaching.
This passage speaks to my heart (being a preacher/teacher) and directs my actions also, which is why I shared on Facebook Dr. Patterson’s public apology and applauded him for this action. I agree with many others who say this apology may not go far enough, but I believe that this biblical process has worked exactly by design. The Church publicly called for repentance, and Dr. Patterson publicly showed humility and repentance.
For those of you uncomfortable with the public nature of this process, or those of you outside of the Church or Baptist tradition, I want to tell you that this is exactly what we want to happen. When our leaders sin, (which will happen…they’re human) the Church has the responsibility to point out the mistake and call for correction. Then we expect our Christian leaders, committed to The Way of Jesus Christ, to show humility and repent of the sin and take action to avoid that sin in the future. So I hope this whole process is both a warning to pastors who think themselves bigger than they actually are, and an encouragement to the Church to expect righteousness from one another and to offer grace to one another when that righteousness is tarnished. May the Church always function this way.